On the surface, this barely seems worth discussing.
You know every question you ask ChatGPT (or your AI of choice) uses incredible amounts of energy and water. Not great for the planet. You know AI is ruining the career prospects of countless talented people. You know you should try to resist its pull if you don’t want to be enslaved by AI overlords in the coming decades (joking…sort of!).
But it is incredibly hard to resist the lure of AI.
Especially as neurodivergent people.
Because AI has its uses.
Who among us hasn’t used it to help us come up with a metaphor for that social media post we’re writing? Or to provide 24 hr customer chat support. Or to automate stock reordering? Maybe even to sense-check a new business idea.
I personally couldn’t run my business without Otter.ai, which I use to transcribe client meetings. As a dyslexic business owner it’s invaluable!
But while we can’t deny the perks of AI – the cost, the availability, the speed of use, and the fact that interacting with it involves zero social anxiety – could it really replace working with a human VA?
Even if we put all ethical arguments aside and focus solely on the benefits it could bring your business?
Well, call me biased, but I don’t think so.
Off the top of my head, there are at least 9 reasons why a human VA will always trump an AI VA, especially for neurodivergent folks.
1. The importance of genuine relationships
Over time, a human VA will get to know you — the real you.
We build real relationships with our clients and that comes with a degree of emotional attunement. We’ll be able to pick up on subtle cues — tone of voice, unspoken stress, energy levels — and adjust our approach accordingly.
For example, there may be times when you need tough love to push you through an episode of procrastination and we all know that AI assistants largely tell us exactly what we want to hear, whether or not that’s actually what we need at that moment.
For many neurodivergent people, feeling truly understood rather than processed makes a significant difference in trust and comfort.
2. Flexible, adaptive communication
Once that genuine relationship is established, your human VA can naturally shift how they communicate with you — they can be more direct, more patient, or offer more or fewer details — based on what’s working in real time.
They can recognize when a script isn’t landing and improvise in ways AI still struggles with.
3. Executive function support with added nuance
Tasks like managing a calendar or breaking down projects aren’t just mechanical.
A human VA will notice that a task has been postponed five times and gently ask the question ‘why?’. They can help you troubleshoot procrastination, or push back if your workload looks overwhelming.
They won’t just execute instructions without thought – they’ll centre your needs, abilities and energy levels too.
4. Navigating ambiguous social situations
Neurodivergent individuals sometimes need help decoding social dynamics — a tricky email, a tense meeting, an unclear request from a colleague. A human VA can offer real-world social intuition and nuanced judgment that AI lacks.
5. Accountability and motivation
Human connection creates a sense of accountability that AI can’t replicate. Knowing a real person will check in can be a stronger motivator for task completion than an automated chatbot reminder.
(After all, how many times have you set a reminder on your phone, then completely ignored it?!)
6. Handling the unexpected
Life has a habit of throwing us curveballs.
When plans fall apart or something emotionally difficult comes up, your human VA can respond with real empathy, use their own lived experience to help improvise a solution, and provide genuine reassurance.
And when those curveballs are coming one after that other, that’s worth far more to your frazzled nervous system than a canned supportive phrase.
7. Consistency of a known person
Having one consistent person who deeply knows your preferences, triggers, routines, and working style removes the cognitive load of re-explaining yourself constantly — leaving you with far more mental and emotional energy to use on other things.
8. Lived experience
AI has a textbook idea of neurodivergence and disability. And that will never trump lived experience.
I haven’t learned about neurodivergence from blog posts or TikTok. I’ve been navigating the neurotypical world my entire life. And that’s exactly why most, if not all, of my clients have chosen to work with me.
They know they are free to ask questions, share worries, challenges, insights, and experiences, and know that I can usually relate in a genuine way that AI can’t replicate.
And sometimes that empathy and insight from one neurodivergent brain to another is exactly what’s needed.
9. A sense of community
The neurodivergent community is one of the most supportive I’ve encountered. So your ND VA won’t just execute tasks and then forget you exist.
They’ll champion you to other people too. When they’re out networking and meet someone who’d be your ideal client, they’ll pass on your details. Or if you’re looking for a new collaboration, they can pass on personal recommendations.
Creating that sense of community is one thing AI will never master and it counts for an awful lot!
I don’t want to demonise AI. It’s not great for the planet and I hate the fact it’s replacing or making working life harder for countless professionals, especially those working in the more creative fields.
Yet, as neurodivergent people, we do have additional challenges and AI can certainly help level the playing field (like my use of AI for transcribing meetings).
So I’m definitely not urging you to avoid it altogether.
Rather, I think the ideal solution for most of us is a hybrid business model, where we use AI for automating routine tasks and use a real human for tasks that require nuance, genuine empathy or understanding, and tasks that rely on the quality of relationship, not just executing instructions on autopilot.
If you’re currently looking for a human VA for those nuanced tasks, I’d love to support you! Book your free discovery call now to find out how I could help.
